English and Existentialism: responding to my own blog prompt
I think Applebee is on to something when he writes, ”The English classroom should be what it has always sought to become: the place where students learn to master the power of words and symbols–theirs and others” (73). The key here is the word symbols, because in essence, words are symbols. I think that Applebee gets the essence of what we should be focusing on; the platonic ideal of the English classroom– communication, in whatever form it comes in. This leaves a lot of room for interpretation, as it should. There are so many ways that human beings convey meaning it boggles the mind. As Amanda said in her blog, the whole world is a text. So what part of human existence, past present and future do we focus on in our classrooms? That indeed is the question. Answer? Well, whatever interests both teacher and student. A workshop approach is probably in order here. There needs to be room for students to explore, question, create, and design–but not necessarily about the same things. There needs to be opportunity to embrace “all of the tools and media available” (73) as Applebee says; opportunity to use the power of technology in order to transform both the individual and the community.
Descartes once said, Cogito Ergo Sum: “I think, therefore I am.” In whatever medium that we engage students, the act of thinking is primary. And with the act of thinking is a validation of existence itself. I am here, alive. I am the eyes of the world. Or invoking a Whitmanesque idea, everything that happens is filtered through me. That’s what I want my students to get. Here is the world ladies and gentlemen, now go ahead and start reading! It’s a fascinating place, there’s a helluva lot to learn- there’s a lot to choose from. What do you want to know? What are you curious about? What means something to you? Here’s what I’m into; let me share it with you. Oh, you think Bob Dylan’s corny? You like Eminem? Have you written any lyrics? Do you want to? Did you know you could get yourself some exposure on myspace and youtube? Oh, of course you already knew that. Do you read Rolling Stone? Go to their website and check it out; what did you think? You like reading about musicians? that’s great! How about writing about musicians? awesome! If you want to create your own music magazine as a project, I’d let you work on it everyday. We could even publish it online. Maybe some other students want to get involved.
Perhaps a classroom where students are in the forefront of creating the curriculum may seem potentially chaotic, but if the entire world is a text to be read and added to, our decisions about what part of this world students should engage in are just as arbitrary as theirs; perhaps even more arbitrary considering that we often times have no idea where our students are coming from, on many different levels. We can decide what part of the world we want to explore, but we should never assume that our students have the same interests. If we’re lucky, we can inspire them to love some of the same things we love, or at least understand why we might love them. But really, we should respect the fact that their existence is just as valid as ours, young though they may be. They furnish their part toward future. They furnish their part toward the soul.

I also liked the Applebee line that you quoted here. As you say, communication is a key in English education. I think you and Amanda are right when you are saying that everything is a text, and we need to teach our students using as many different texts as we can.
Great post, Jon! What you’ve written here reflects a true sense of respect and willingness to understand each student that comes into your life as a single, unique being with his/her own interests, values, and ways of thinking which, to me, is one of the most important work you can do as an educator. Though, like you said, we may hope to inspire our students to love the things we love, we should not make it our work to impose our value systems upon them and, in the process, devalue theirs. The ELA classroom should be a celebration of each student’s uniqueness, point of view, and contributions.
Amanda
I really like your list of “questions” to engage students as intellectual/content producers. Great Jon! I also am in agreement with what you say in this post about the artibrariness of the curricula we teach. If there is one point I would want to get across in 541 (and in 506) it’s that one. Any curriculum is a construct which is simply the product of particular powerful Discourses. I believe those Discourses and the small “d” discourse around them is changing rapidly. We could do far worse than to look to our students as proof of that as well as the curriculum “designers” who will help us shape these next decades work in ELA classrooms. KES